Based on 13265 reviews
Mystery Short Sleeve
Chelsey Eslinger
Mystery T!

I ordered one for me and my daughters they couldn’t have picked better! Mine was yellow and had flowers which I loved and her shirt was her favorite teal/mint green color! We love them!

Love the Bundles!

Literally flawless! Love getting mystery shirts! Made me step out of my box on my normal colors!


Great quality tshirt and I love the design

Great purchase!

Everything that I received was beautiful! Most of my wardrobe is made up by dark/solid pieces and these shirts bring in some much needed bright colors! I should’ve ordered down a size but you can never go wrong with oversized t shirts. Totally worth the price.

Spring Mystery Bag
shelly stahl
Spring bag

Very nice love the designs on shirts

A little bit disappointed, but just a tiny bit!

I ordered the Ultimate Spring mystery bag, and got 3 gorgeous tshirts, socks, scrunchy, straws, bracelets, a couple of stickers, and a hoodie. I’m a tiny bit disappointed I didn’t get a fleece, but it’s okay. The rest of the stuff was great!

Spring Mystery bag

I love the designs on the shirts I got. They are so soft and comfortable. The bag is so roomy and great quality.
Very happy with my purchase and I’ll be buying more.

Spring Mystery Bag
bailly bounds
Shelly Cove is amazing!!

Hi!! I love my Shelly Cove Order!! I’m currently wearing one of the shirts and my scrunchie right now! They are so comfy!!! I love everything that they do!! Definitely a great purchase!!

Spring Mystery Bag
Seth Hockaday
Great value

I enjoyed this mystery bag. Starting off, I did get stuff like bracelets and straws that I personally won’t use (I already have dozens of metal straws and the bracelets aren’t my style).
The stickers and tote bag are awesome.
And finally, I love both T-Shirts. Both look great and very comfortable.

Spring Mystery Bag
Quinn Schoonover
Awesome purchase!!

This purchase was so incredibly awesome! Everything from the stickers to the t shirts were absolutely perfect. Definitely will be ordering from here again. I highly recommend!!

Love it!

I love the simplicity of the white t-shirt and the 70's inspired design on this shirt. Looking forward for more designs! And I will say it again, if you had Youth sizes, I would totally buy Mama and son matching Tees.

Happy Daisies
Randi Robinson

Love it

Fun and exciting envelope

Love getting the exciting new stickers every month! I teach so I used the turtle stickers with names as some word problems we were doing.

Incredible Customer Service

Had a delivery issue. Contacted Customer Service; they were prompt to reply, pleasant, helpful, and eager to solve my situation.
Very pleased with my mystery bag!! Shirts are good quality and the prints beautiful! Unisex sizing, hope to see women’s cut in the future!

Stickers haven’t arrived

I have not received my monthly subscription stickers yet

Tropical Fern
MaryAnn Waseline
A Little Disappointed

I love the color pink but I thought there would be more darker colors in my turtle. I love the shirt, always of good quality and washes awesome, just the colors.

I have not received them

They have not arrived

Spring Mystery Bag
Teresa Chumley

The selection of shirts in my mystery pack were shirts I would have chosen myself, and I love each one. The accessories and bag were ok. I received orange bracelets, not a fan of orange, but will make a cute gift for me to give someone else. All in all, I am pleased with what I was sent.


Super cute turtle necklace. Love it! Doesn’t turn my neck green either!

Classic Spring Mystery Bag

The mystery bag did not disappoint! I loved everything I received and will definitely be ordering again!!

Spring Mystery Bag
Jaime Lowrey
Mini Mystery Bag

love it... nice items! love that we can track our turtle. :)

Retro Keychain
Jaime Lowrey
Retro Keychain

love this keychain!! its very cool... love it!

Spring Mystery Bag
Gabriela Cornejo
Amazing kit!

I loved this kit! Everything was great!

Blue Storm Tie-Dye Hoodie
Elizabeth Jones
Blue Tie Dye Hoodie

I love this hoodie. It looks and fits great. The color isn't as vibrant as it appears online, but I still love it!

Night Owl Lounge Set
Jeanette Beebe

Shelly Cove metal thing came off after 1st wash. It was washed inside out.