Mystery Accessory

    FG icon

    Old price $ 12.00 $ 8.00

    • 🔙Free Exchanges
    • 💝Over $200K Donated
    • 🆓Free stickers in every order
    • 🐢Track a turtle with every purchase

    Free Shipping Over $75

    Want a little extra something but can't decide what to pick? No worries! Let us choose a cute, fun accessory for you ❓✨ 🎉 💝


    You'll get one of the following items:

    • Jewelry 💍
    • Scrunchie 🎀
    • Key Chain 🔑
    • Socks 🧦
    • Straw Pack ♻️
    • Tote 🛍


    A portion of each sale goes directly to 💖🐢

    Frequently Asked Questions

    Need more help? Contact Us!

    Every order gets a physical postcard with a unique serial code. Using your special code on our website allows you to get a behind-the-scenes look at a REAL turtle being rehabilitated at the sea turtle rescue!

    Shelly Cove's mission statement is to donate a *minimum* of 10% of net profits annually to sea turtle rescue. In most cases, we are able to donate more - even up to 1/3 of profits!

    So far, we have donated over $200,00 to sea turtle rehabilitation, and other great causes like clean water initiatives, local food banks, scholarship funds, and more!

    Only the best! We use premium garment-dyed, 100% cotton tees. All printed in-house to give you the best garment possible. This prevents shrinking, and gives you a shirt that will last years!

    You heard correctly! Every order gets a free pack of stickers, as well as a turtle tracking card.

    We are a small team, but aim to ship all orders within 3 business days. If you're in the U.S., this means your order will arrive within a week in most cases!

    If you're not sure what size to buy, please reach out to customer service and we can help! If your order arrives and doesn't fit right, we have an easy, FREE exchange policy within 30 days!

    • Free Returns

    • Over $200K Donated

    • Stickers In Each Order

    • Track a Turtle

    Customer Reviews

    Based on 21 reviews
    Donna Derby
    Love it! Love it! Love it!

    Was going to give as a gift but once I saw this bracelet, I had to keep it for myself!!!

    Loved the mystery bracelet.

    It is the gold turtle and I think my great granddaughter will love it.

    Elle Gato
    Mystery accessory

    I didn’t have any expectations with what I would receive so I was pleasantly surprised to receive a beautiful and strong ring!! It’s beautifully made and a fun accessory

    Natalie B

    The cutest accessory!

    Great deal

    I ordered 4 of the mystery stocking stuffers and each one was different. I loved each one but now have the difficult decision of which ones to keep and which ones to give away.I probably would have been happy with any of the stocking stuffers that was available. I'm just happy that it wasn't 4 of the same thing!

    Michael Dwyer
    Great website.

    I love your website and the stuff you are doing. My daughter is crazy about turtles and I saw a girl with a shirt on that had a turtle on the back and Shelly cove on it. So I checked it out. Glad I did. Great products and the mystery stocking stuffer was so cool. She's gonna love em.

    Jennifer Fehrman
    It's a Xmas gift.

    But I know my daughter will LOVE to be able to track a sea turtle and the other items in the mystery bag. The ring not sure will fit but she will be happy

    Katherine Petrus

    Ordered two mystery bags, hoping to get different bracelets but they were the same. Now my daughter and I use they as a mommy and me bracelets :)

    Fawn Schraffenberger
    Mystery bag

    Was so glad I purchased! It had the best surprises inside and I live the quality of the shirts.

    Valerie Trani

    A cute little silver ring. I like it! Fits my pinkie fine